Hi, sorry for the wait, so without further ado, let's get rlling
Banner:It's simple, effective, blending and quite pleasent.
Nothing much else to say
Background:A grass field for the grounds of a football forum, brilliant
It fits in really nicly with your forum's theme, you can't see the edges of the images.
NavBar:A nice job
But the light blue doesn't really blend n with the green of the grass background or the red in the banner.
Forum Icons:A little simple but ok, it's not a negative point either
Who's Online:Er...
Well, for one it's small, most forum's ave lightly larger ones.
Secondly, you'd need to review the colors of your T-shirts; the orange is a bit 'out of the blue'
Topic Icons:I don't see the link with football...
For the popular, I'd advise a football rather than a bomb
New and Reply:Very classic, and not muh link to the forum's main theme.
Yet teir graphical quality catches up
Topic Buttons:A little too simple here
Relation with the forum's theme : 6/10 (30%)
Coherency of the whole design 4/10 (15%)
Graphic quality : 9/10 (15%)
Accessibility and ergonomy (text legibility, icon sizes, effect on the eyes) : 8/10 (20%)
Customization : 8/10 (20%)
=> 6.95/10
Keep up the good work
It's lookin' good but it still needs a little bit work